This one 11-year-old chart explains the problem with hydrogen fuel-cell vehicles

Posted on
2015 Hyundai Tucson Fuel Cell at hydrogen fueling station, Fountain Valley, CA

2015 Hyundai Tucson Gas Cell at hydrogen fueling station, Fountain Valley, CA

Enlarge Picture

At this time, there are roughly 750,000 plug-in electrical automobiles on U.S. roads and about three,800 powered by hydrogen gas cells.

Proponents of every sort of auto argue strenuously that their powertrain is a greater approach to produce automobiles with zero emissions from the tailpipe.

Electrical vehicles may be charged at house in a single day, and electrical energy in lots of areas is way cheaper than gasoline on a per-mile foundation, say the plug-in automobile supporters.

DON’T MISS: Why a Fiat 500e driver acquired a Honda Readability Gas Cell as his subsequent inexperienced automotive: low value

Ah, however hydrogen automobiles have far longer ranges, must be fueled much less typically, and make use of the acquainted mannequin of visiting a fueling station that drivers are already used to, counter the hydrogen proponents.

It’s miles too early to know the way this battle will play out. Some analysts counsel electrical energy could also be the popular mode for smaller passenger automobiles, whereas hydrogen is best suited to such giant automobiles as semi tractors, even perhaps full-size SUVs.

However there’s one metric through which it’s totally onerous for hydrogen to come back out forward: vitality use.

Energy requirements for vehicle powered by hydrogen (L) vs electricity (R) [image: Ulf Bossel]

Power necessities for automobile powered by hydrogen (L) vs electrical energy (R) [image: Ulf Bossel]

Enlarge Picture

A single chart, printed in a December 2006 article on reveals the added steps required to course of hydrogen and switch it again onto electrical energy to drive the electrical motor that powers a hydrogen fuel-cell automobile’s wheels.

When you begin with the identical kilowatt-hour, regardless of the supply (from coal-powered to thoroughly renewable), utilizing that vitality to make hydrogen produces fewer miles on the highway than it does when used to cost an electrical automotive.


READ THIS: 10 Questions On Hydrogen Gas-Cell Automobiles To Ask Toyota, Honda & Hyundai (Oct 2014)

That interprets to a decrease carbon footprint per mile for the electrical automotive towards the hydrogen one.

The numbers solely come out evenly when all vitality is renewable, at which level the carbon footprints are so negligible that any minor variations in manufacturing and transport probably do not matter.

2015 Hyundai Tucson Fuel Cell, 2016 Toyota Mirai at hydrogen fueling station, Fountain Valley, CA

2015 Hyundai Tucson Gas Cell, 2016 Toyota Mirai at hydrogen fueling station, Fountain Valley, CA

Enlarge Picture

Till that time, which even underneath probably the most remarkably optimistic situation is not going to arrive earlier than 2050—if not 2100—the vitality required to drive a mile on hydrogen is larger than that wanted to drive a mile in a battery-electric automotive.

It’s attainable to create research that present extra favorable outcomes for hydrogen, partly by cherry-picking knowledge to make use of completely different grids with completely different carbon intensities.

However wherever the identical kilowatt-hour, from the identical supply, with the identical carbon depth is used both to cost a battery or to create hydrogen gas for a automobile, the electrical automotive wins.

CHECK OUT: Hyundai On Hydrogen Gas-Cell Autos: Critiquing Its Claims (Feb 2014)

If the coverage targets for zero-emission automobiles are to remove tailpipe emissions, then each varieties of automobiles rating equally, because the water vapor from the hydrogen automobile is innocent.

But when the objective is to radically cut back the emissions of the greenhouse fuel carbon dioxide related to highway automobiles, electrical vehicles will all the time be higher until all hydrogen is produced renewably however most batteries are charged utilizing non-renewable vitality.

It is necessary to notice right here that hydrogen automobiles usually have a decrease carbon footprint than most gasoline vehicles as we speak—and that California requires renewable sources for use for not less than one third of the vitality used to make hydrogen, which as we speak is essentially derived kind pure fuel.

Hat tip: Invoice Verthein

قالب وردپرس

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *